These two views are opposite, and each of them is based on a part of the evidence. This is the view of the Hanbalis. This is the view of Maalik and was narrated in one report from Ahmad. What this means is that wakefulness is the string that ties the anal sphincter, i. Al-Teebi said: When a person is awake, he keeps control of what is in his stomach but when he sleeps he loses that control and his muscles relax.
End quote. It makes no difference if the sleeper is lying down, sitting leaning on something or sitting without leaning. What matters is the level of awareness. Its isnaad contains some weakness, but there are corroborating reports that support it, such as the hadeeth of Safwaan mentioned above, thus it is counted as a hasan hadeeth. Related topic: Does fart invalidate wudu?
Re: Is wudu invalidated if one dozes off to sleep for a while? Wa'Salam sis. That brother-bugger is one of the many crazies. After performing a full wudu, one can doze off to sleep for whatever stretch of time, wudu does not get invalidated, unless they have a sexual dream and the body reacts to it, causing pollution.
Needless to say, farting in sleep does not invalidate the wudu. So, upon awakening, whether or not you recall farting during your sleep, doesn't matter. Either way wudu is intact. Of course, resting your back against the back of the chair or sleeping upright it totally insignificant. One simply needs to view the Quran as the Sole Criterion and use one's common sense. The only cause for invalidating wudu after waking from sleep would be sexual pollution.
If that happens one will know it. Other than that, whether one farts, laughs, snores or screams seeing a nightmare or even experiences sleep paralysis Wudu stays fine. I would surmise that the source of such madness as related by that weird brother is partly hadith and partly gossip. Exactly sis, that's precisely what I had in mind too.
Re: Does sleeping or dozing annul wudu? Quote from: Heba E. Husseyn on October 27, , am. Then, they woke up and performed the prayer [i. Thus, we explained the above-narrated Hadeeth to mean the sleep while sitting with keeping one's buttocks firmly on the floor due to other several Ahadeeth that state nullification of ablution in such a case of sleeping.
So, we differentiate between kinds of sleep and the Hadeeth related to each state. This is to avoid any contradiction between Ahadeeth and to show agreement as it is in fact. Imam Ash-Shaafi'i holds the same opinion. Written by Molana Ishaaq Hussain. Checked and approved by Mufti Mohammed Tosir Miah. Darul Ifta Birmingham. This answer was collected from DarulIftaBirmingham.
Frogs coming into my house Facing the Qibla What is tahir mutahira, and tahir ghayr mutahira.
0コメント